Year: 2026 | Month: September | Volume 19 | Issue 3

Evaluating the Multi-Dimensional Sustainability Trade-offs of Autonomous Agricultural Systems: An AHP-TOPSIS Decision Model for Precision UAV Spraying in India

Livert Mudzingenyama and Mahesh Vinayak Hadole
DOI:10.30954/0974-1712.03.2026.3

Abstract:

Autonomous agricultural technologies are gaining more and more traction to enhance the efficiency of resources and precision of operation; however, their sustainability needs to be assessed going beyond their technical performance, and taking into consideration the environmental, economic, social and governance trade-offs. This study designed an integrated Analytic Hierarchy Process –Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (AHP –TOPSIS) model to evaluate the three crop protection technologies in India namely, autonomous unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) spraying, tractor mounted boom spraying and conventional backpack spraying. Secondary empirical data were used to assess the status of fourteen indicators for the four domains of environmental, economic, social, technical and governance. The environmental dimension (0.3523) was given the highest priority, followed by the economic dimension (0.2408), technical dimension (0.1723), social dimension (0.1173) and governance dimension (0.1173). The spraying using UAV showed the best efficiency in terms of field capacity (3.03 ha h-1), application efficiency (95%) and pesticide usage (1.84 kg ha-1), as well as the best benefit–cost ratio (2.45). The UAV spraying option was ranked best with a closeness coefficient (Cᵢ) of 0.6996 and the tractor-mounted boom was ranked second with a Cᵢ value of 0.4555, while conventional backpack spraying was ranked third with a Cᵢ value of 0.3090. While there are environmental and operational benefits to UAVs, there are trade-offs with regard to smallholder access, regulatory compliance, technical skills and cyber security. The results prove that increased agricultural autonomy is not necessarily synonymous with full sustainability. The framework suggested here offers a clear decision support mechanism to consider ‘resource efficiency’, ‘socio-economic’, and ‘governance’ issues and has the potential to assist responsible use of autonomous agro-chemical technologies in India.



© This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited



Highlights

  • An integrated AHP–TOPSIS framework evaluated agricultural spraying technologies across five sustainability dimensions and 14 indicators.
  • UAV spraying ranked highest (Cᵢ = 0.6996), demonstrating strong resource-use efficiency and operational performance.
  • UAVs offer substantial sustainability benefits, but smallholder access, regulatory compliance, technical skills and cybersecurity remain important adoption trade-offs.


Print This Article Email This Article to Your Friend

International Journal of Agriculture Environment & Biotechnology(IJAEB)| In Association with AAEB

48817044 - Visitors since February 20, 2019